Across Canada and the United States, a playful holiday debate returns to the airwaves, inviting fans to compare two very different Christmas icons. On one side stands Justin Bieber, a pop sensation whose latest holiday album has stirred fresh chatter around seasonal playlists. On the other, Billy Gilman, the original Boy Christmas, who released ONE VOICE in 2000 when he was just twelve. In memory, Gilman is tied to a single, memorable moment: Warm and Fuzzy, a song that fans recall with a mix of fondness and astonishment. The question isn’t simply about who sings the best. It touches on how a single holiday tune can linger through years of fans, reappearing in family gatherings, retro playlists, and meme-worthy discussions that pop up every season. The contrast is ripe for a conversation that spans generations and national borders, especially for audiences in North America who love a good holiday storyline.
This retrospective look invites listeners to revisit the era when young artists began leaving lasting impressions on country and pop stages alike, while curious newcomers also discover how a simple melody can become a memory anchor. It’s a reminder that the spirit of the season travels with music, moving through past and present with a shared sense of wonder. The matchup also raises questions about how fame evolves when a holiday song becomes the centerpiece of an artist’s narrative, and how fans in Canada and the United States decide which tunes still spark joy when the snow starts to fall. [citation: fan commentary and media roundups]